Have you tried NYx Powder Louder eyebrow pencil?
I usually opt for a more natural brow look but when my makeup is dramatic, I need a brow to match and that's when I reach for my Powder Louder pencil.
It's an eyebrow pencil that comes out as a Powder. I'm not quite sure how that works but it does! This makes it super easy to draw with but also fills in your brows effortlessly. I always set with my brow glue afterwards and have had no problem with it smudging or fading.