I received these from NYX and what can I say?! As usual NYX never let's us down. This new Duck Plump Plumping Lip Liner is a game changer! You definitely get the tingling sensation. As for the Lip IV...WOW that formula is to die for π i love it. Now I'm not a huge lover of gloss due its stickiness but this isn't your typical gloss! , I love it! It's silky smooth and isn't drying in the slightest!